Tips for safe harbour against port construction risks

By Cao Shan and Lu Yuchen, City Development Law Firm

Port construction is closely connected to a country’s politics, economy and trade, and changes in the external environment will directly affect decision making on port investments. On the other hand, as the construction period and payback period are relatively long, the possibility of various uncertainties arising increases and the stability of the projected returns decreases. This column will discuss preliminary
suggestions for risk prevention.

曹珊,建纬律师事务所高级合伙人; 卢昱陈,建纬律师事务所律师助理 Cao Shan is a senior partner and Lu Yuchen is a paralegal at City Development Law Firm
Cao Shan is a senior partner and Lu Yuchen is a paralegal at City Development Law Firm

Systemic risks

Force majeure. The requirements of ports regarding natural conditions are stringent, with wind direction, precipitation and sea conditions greatly influencing port operations, and in times of war, port cities can even become military targets. Prevention is key in the case of force majeure risks, and accordingly, careful thought is needed when choosing the location. The project company may also take out property insurance to shift risk onto the insurer.

Political risks. These include political instability, government confiscation or forced acquisition of the project, premature revocation of the project company’s concession, changes in tax policies or import-export restrictions. Political risks are beyond the control of the individual or an enterprise so prevention is the best policy. First, even if the profit rate is high, it is better to avoid constructing a project in a country or region where political risks are great. Second, when entering into the agreement, the private party should strive to procure the provision of security by the local government against political risks such that, if a political risk arises, the government will bear the majority of the losses. This is because a port construction project is unlike a pure commercial project in that a port, as an international logistics platform and a base for the entry and exit of foreign vessels, has a foreign element and impinges on the sovereignty of territorial waters and the economic security of the state. Accordingly, the political sensitivity of a government to a port project may be greater than for the construction of other infrastructure.

Economic risks. First, the project company should consider executing financing and loan agreements with the government and banks in an effort to fix the interest rates within a reasonable range, to pass on part of the interest risks. Second, the construction period for a port is relatively long, causing greater effect of exchange rates and inflation. When executing the concession agreement with the government, the project company may propose that pricing be done in a hard currency and that settlement be carried out at the exchange rate in effect at the time of settlement. The project company may also consider a price agreement with the government so that when inflation arises the company can suitably increase port charge rates.

Regulation risks. With the public paying greater attention to the impact of industrialization on the environment and health, numerous countries have issued or drafted increasingly stringent laws to protect the environment. Port development and environmental protection are intimately connected, and carelessness in the course of development could have a serious impact on the marine environment. Accordingly, when the private party is preparing to implement a build-operate-transfer (BOT) project, it should pay close attention to environmental legislation, in addition to conventional laws and regulations governing procurement and construction. The private party should apprise itself of the government’s future environmental protection direction, assess the project’s environmental liability risks and formulate a rigorous environmental protection plan to secure approval from the environmental protection authority.

Social risks. Social risks mainly arise from customs and practices, public security, and cultural and social awareness in the place where the port is located. Where the BOT model is to be used, consideration can be given to localization, i.e. giving priority to local private capital and allowing locals to participate in the port’s construction, operation and management, thereby increasing acceptance of the port and adapting to the local customs and practices.

Non-systemic risks

Construction. These risks mainly refer to delayed approvals, extension of the construction period, cost overruns, failure to meet targets projected at the time of design after the project comes on stream, failure to commence operations on schedule, or failure to achieve production targets, resulting in the insufficient cash flow for production and inability to repay debts on time.

In the BOT model, the government, through an invitation of bids, has selected a qualified contractor and transferred a large portion of the project construction risks onto the private party. If conditions permit, the contractor may subcontract works that it would have difficulty in completing, but that do not involve the main project, so as to spread the risks. Raw materials required in large quantities during construction may be purchased from different suppliers to avoid the risk of any one supplier failing to supply on time or increasing its prices. Project insurance for the construction period may be purchased to shift onto the insurer equipment, personal safety and other such risks.

Operating risks. These mainly include technical risks and operation management risks. Technical risks include production stoppages caused by unreliable technology or construction, or inferior equipment. Operation management risks include those arising in various types of management work during operations.

Processes, advanced technology and equipment should be used to the greatest extent possible to minimize waste of resources. At the project preparation stage, the project company should focus on strengthening the project feasibility analysis, and duly carry out analysis management work when selecting the port’s site and hinterland, and its projected future returns.

At the project bid invitation and submission, and the project preliminary design stages, the project company should pay attention to the compliance of the bids and the management of the bid invitation and submission procedure. Once the project agreements have been executed, the project company should carefully examine the conditions and qualifications of the participating parties. Finally, at the project operation and transfer stages, the project company should first carry out personnel management, selecting suitable operating and management personnel to ensure the efficient operation of the project; and additionally carry out the day-to-day management work to ensure the normal operation of the project.




31/F Hong Kong Plaza

283 Huaihai Middle Road

Shanghai 200021 China

电话 Tel:+86 21 5239 3188

传真 Fax:+86 21 5239 3128

电子邮箱 E-mail: subscripton ad blue 2022